• Secure File Transfer
  • Proposal
  • Account Login

Is it Time to Consider a New Plan Design?

April 25, 2019

Is it Time to Consider a New Plan Design?

You may have heard about a “cash balance plan” and wondered whether it would be something advantageous for your retirement savings. A cash balance plan operates a bit differently than traditional retirement plans in that it combines features of both defined benefit and defined contribution plans.

Technically, a cash balance plan is a defined benefit plan, which means it is subject to minimum funding requirements as determined by an enrolled actuary. Likewise, the investment of cash balance plan assets are managed by the employer or an investment manager appointed by the employer on behalf of the participants. Since cash balance plans provide a pre-defined “benefit,” increases and decreases in the value of the actual plan’s investments do not directly affect the amount promised to employees.

For example, if Jane is promised through a cash balance plan a $10,000 account value, then she is entitled to a $10,000 payment, whereas, the actual value of Jane’s account could be $8,000. The employer is responsible for making Jane’s account whole. Or, vice versa, her account could be worth $12,000, yet she is only eligible to claim the $10,000 that is her accrued benefit. 1

Typically, however, an employee benefit is expressed as a hypothetical account balance, giving it a defined contribution “feel.” A participant’s account is credited each year with a “pay credit,” usually a percentage of pay or fixed dollar, and also with an “interest credit,” either a fixed or variable rate that is tied to an index. When a participant is eligible to receive benefits under a cash balance plan, the plan is treated as if it were a defined contribution plan with distributions available at termination of employment in the form of an annuity or a lump sum that can be rolled over into an IRA.

Who are cash balance plans best suited for?

Cash balance plans are especially well suited for self-employed or small business owners with high incomes, since these plans allow high-earning business owners to save more than the $56,000 currently allowed for profit sharing/401(k) plans. Cash balance plans have generous contribution limits – upwards of $200,000 in annual contributions in some cases.

These plans allow for large annual tax deductions because the limitation is on the annual distribution that the plan participant may receive at retirement ($225,000 for 2019), not on the annual contribution to the plan as is the case with profit sharing or 401(k) plans. Employer contributions to a cash balance plan could potentially be three to four times their profit sharing/401(k) contributions and will vary depending on age, income, employee payroll and how much is currently invested in the plan.

Most cash balance plans are designed for the primary benefit of owners or executives of a company. They are usually paired with an existing 401(k) profit sharing plan, which provides participant’s with the ability to defer and yet maximize overall retirement savings. Some candidates include professional practices (doctors, lawyers, accountants, architects, agencies, family owned businesses, to name a few examples) who would like to minimize taxes by putting away their hard-earned dollars into tax-deferred accounts. Additionally, cash balance plans can be appropriate when the owner or executive-level employees are several years older than most of the non-highly compensated employees. For more specifics, it’s best to speak with a retirement plan advisor and third-party administrator for a sample plan design proposal.

This sounds too good to be true, so what’s the catch?

Downsides to sponsoring a cash balance plan include the need to commit to annual minimum funding levels, annual administration fees, investment management fees, and actuarial fees associated with the annual certification requirement showing that the plan is properly funded. Typically, the tax savings are advantageous and far outweigh many of the disadvantages.

Interested, but should I be concerned about cash flow fluctuations?

Businesses that may not want to make the commitment to a cash balance plan or that are not good candidates for it, but would nonetheless like to optimize retirement benefits for executive and other highly compensated employees, may want to consider a profit-sharing plan with an allocation method known as “new comparability” or “cross-testing.”

With the new comparability plan, profit sharing contributions are allocated using the time value of money as a basis to allocate larger contributions to participants closer to retirement age. Depending on the demographic make-up of a company’s work force, the new comparability allocation method can be an effective means of targeting contributions to certain senior highly-compensated employees without committing to funding a defined benefit plan.

What should I do next?

Plan design is largely dependent on the demographics of a business as well as the level of contributions with which the business is most comfortable. For these reasons, consulting with a third-party administrator who specializes in this type design is highly recommended. Your consultant will create a customized illustration using your company’s particular demographics, any existing defined contribution plan, and provide alternative plan designs for review and consideration.

Proper retirement plan design can help you fulfill your company’s retirement plan objectives, such as maximizing benefits to key employees, tax deferral and efficient ways to minimize cost to the company.

If you would like to consider benefit design alternatives that will go beyond the defined contribution limits; then, reach out today for a free initial consultation and illustration.

Daphne Weitzel, CPC, QPA, APA

ABG Retirement Plan Services
456 Fulton Street, Suite 345
Peoria, IL 61602



1 This example is a hypothetical illustration. It is not representative of any specific situation and your results will vary.

This information was developed as a general guide to educate plan sponsors and is not intended as authoritative guidance or tax/legal advice. Each plan has unique requirements and you should consult your attorney or tax advisor for guidance on your specific situation.

Follow our blog!

RSS Feed

Update your RSS Aggregator or RSS App with ABG's Blog Feed.


ABG Retirement Plan Services (ABG) is a regional service office of one of the largest retirement plan administration organizations in the country. (More)

CEFEX Certified - Independent Assessment Report

Follow Us

Contact Us




456 Fulton Street, Suite 345
Peoria, IL 61602